Eye-witnesses have been disbelieved

“The law is settled that if the eye-witnesses have been disbelieved against some accused persons attributed effective roles then the same eyewitnesses cannot be believed against another accused person attributed a similar role unless such eye-witness receive independent corroboration qua the other accused person-----”

“SHAHBAZ versus The STATE” (2016 SCMR 1763),
“TARIQ versus The STATE and others” (2017 SCMR 1672) and
“IMTIAZ alias TAJ versus The STATE and others” (2018 SCMR 344).

Used in Judgment of:
Lahore High Court
Criminal Appeal
383-12