Required to exercise much greater care and circumspection while appraising evidence.

Such rule is derived by us from the observation of Hon’ble Supreme Court of Pakistan expressed in Muhammad Zaman v. The State (2014 SCMR 749) which is as under:-

“The tragedy may have been enacted by Mukhtar who has gone into hiding or Munawar who has been acquitted because the deceased Shabbir was alleged to have illicit relations with their sister, but many who have no visible nexus with this part of the story have also been roped in. It is so because it is customary in this part of the country to throw wide the net of implication to rope in all those who could possibly pursue the case or do something to save the skin of the one who is innocent or who is actually responsible for the commission of crime. The Courts, therefore, is required to exercise much greater care and circumspection while appraising evidence.”

Used in Judgment of
Lahore High court
Criminal Appeal
279-13

Post a Comment

0 Comments

close