Non-receiving of any firearm injury by PW during the occurrence and his accurate attribution of each injury of the deceased and injured to each accused ...........

 Non-receiving of any firearm injury by PW during the occurrence and his accurate attribution of each injury of the deceased and injured to each accused specifically with specific firearms casts serious doubt about his presence at the place of occurrence and his planation as an eye witness of the occurrence due to previous enmity with the nominated accused cannot be ruled out of consideration particularly when his testimony is lacking independent corroboration in material aspects.

Criminal Appeals Nos. 505 to 507 of 2019
Muhammad Akhtar and others
Muhammad Arshad
Vs
The State